The Problem:
The national October 22 Coalition to Stop Police Brutality annually
holds a march and rally against police brutality. During the planning
of this year's event there was a struggle from within the Chicago
chapter over whether or not to include a speaker from the lesbian-bi-gay-transgender
liberation movement. The Revolutionary Communist Party (RCP) position
on queer liberation is that "gayness" is a disease of
the capitalist system that will be "cured" with reeducation
after the revolution. The RCP, lead organizers of the event, tried
first to avoid the issue of having a queer speaker, then used
the argument that "there were too many speakers on the program"
to allow queer representation. RCP members even said that having
anyone from the Young Womyn's Day of Action Coalition was sufficient
representation for both womyn and queers. Eventually it was agreed
that a speaker from the queer community would be on the rally
program.
But attitudes lead to actions. At the rally a member of a group
called the Hebrew Black Israelites - an organization affiliated
with the Gang Truce Movement - was added to the program on the
day of the event. This individual made anti-gay statements on
the day of the event. There were some boos and hisses from the
listeners, but not enough.
Response:
The Autonomous Zone, a resource center for radical, anti-authoritarian
organizers and activists, takes the position that a narrow fight
against police brutality in which some issues are highlighted
and others ignored or relegated to "middle-class identity
issue" status is not the best strategy for building a movement.
A radical front against police brutality must be anti-racist,
-sexist, -heterosexist, and -agist while being class conscious
if it is to become a movement, and especially a movement that
will win. Queers and womyn and queer womyn and poor queers and
african womyn queers (etc.) can be and are victims of oppression
and police brutality. They don't need "reeducation."They
demand liberation against the hierarchies of capitalism, religious
institutions and other agents of oppression.
The October 22 Coalition should be a vehicle for all victims of
police brutality, not just heterosexual men of color. Consciousness-raising
and conscious action is required for any true, united front anti-racist,
-sexist, -heterosexist, and -agist mobilization against police
brutality.
Update:
Since the time the above was written, the October 22 Coalition
to Stop Police Brutality met with representatives of the Autonomous
Zone Collective. Proposals were made to invite queer people into
the Coalition, to tell their stories of brutality by cops; and
to establish a dialogue with the Young Womyn Day of Action Coalition.
The October 22 Coalition recognizes that they made an error by
not making a public response to the anti-queer statements made
by the Hebrew Black Israelites at last year's rally.
Members of the Autonomous Zone and Anti-Racist Action Coalition
will help see that true reflection of diversity in the further
work of the October 22 Coalition.
[Editors' note: the Revolutionary Communist Party, which sets much of the agenda within the October 22 Coalition, has had problems in areas other than its attitudes towards homosexuality. In the early '80s, the RCP claimed that native peoples of the Americas ate their own shit prior to the arrival of the enlightened Europeans - a racist notion through and through.]